| Year | Player | Competition | Opponent |
| 1981 | Doug Humann | Men's C - F Team | Tasmania FL |
| 1981 | John Steven | Men's C - F Team | Tasmania FL |
| 1982 | Doug Humann | Men's C - F Team | Tasmania FL |
| 1982 | John Steven (Vice-Captain) | Men's C - F Team | Tasmania FL |
| 1985 | Stephen Trist | Men's C - F Team | NSWAFL |
| 1995 | Adam Kyriacou (Vice-Captain) | Men's C - F Team | SAAFL |
| 2001 | Nigel Credlin | Men's C - D4 Team / A - B Team | SFL / VCFL |
| 2001 | Brent Christie | Men's Under 19 Team | VCFL |
| 2002 | Nigel Credlin | Men's A - B Team | SAAFL |
| 2003 | Nigel Credlin | Men's C - D4 Team / A - B Team | SFL / WAAFL |
| 2004 | Brent Christie | Men's Under 23 Team | WAAFL |
| 2004 | Nigel Credlin | Men's A - B Team | SAAFL |
| 2004 | Andrew Durling | Men's C - D4 Team | SFL |
| 2005 | Brendan Ryan | Men's Under 23 Team | WAAFL |
| 2005 | Kane Batzloff | Men's C - D4 Team | SFL |
| 2006 | David Mitchell | Men's C - D4 Team | SFL |
| 2009 | Tim Hazell | Men's A - B Team | EFL |
| 2012 | Simon Bennett | Men's C - D4 Team | EFL |
| 2012 | Warren Carlyle | Men's C - D4 Team | EFL |
| 2012 | Jackson Eade | Men's Under 23 Team / A-B Team | WAAFL / AFL Sydney |
| 2018 | Rhiannon Green | Women's | Adelaide Footy League |
| 2019 | Rhiannon Green | Women's | AFL Goldfields |
